Subsequent to the “Camp Fire” which destroyed Paradise California, on November 8, 2018, President Trump blamed California’s forestry policies saying that “There is no reason for these massive, deadly and costly forest fires in California except that forest management is so poor,” and Trump threatened to withhold federal payments to California. Trump has repeatedly blamed forest management in California, when climate change is clearly increasing the fire risk thanks to years of low rainfall and increasing temperatures. It doesn’t matter if forest management is bad, the forests are dry tinder and any spark can blossom into a huge fire very quickly. Further, the area in question is a National Forest managed by federal authorities. Finally, there is a report from PG&E of a power line problem at the epicenter of the fire, near Pulga California, fitting a pattern of lax maintenance that has caused several other fires.
There are two massive wildfires currently active in California. The Camp Fire is one, which has more-or-less destroyed Paradise and is now threatening Chico California. The other is in Ventura County, and is threatening both Thousand Oaks (which just suffered the latest mass gun shooting earlier this week), and Malibu. Curiously it is late in the year, most wildfires occur in the summer. In this post I’ll focus on the “Camp Fire” because a) I have a PG&E report indicating a very likely cause, b) I have visited Pulga many times and know the terrain very well.
The incident began the morning of November 8, 2018. PG&E sent a report (embedded below) to the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) saying:
On November 8, 2018, at approximately 0615 hours, PG&E experienced an outage on the Caribou-Palermo 115 kV Transmission line in Butte County. In the afternoon of November 8, PG&E observed by aerial patrol damage to a transmission tower on the Caribou-Palermo 115 kV Transmission line, approximately one mile north-east of the town of Pulga, in the area of the Camp Fire. This information is preliminary.
News reports are that the fire began that morning near Pulga, and spread down the valley towards Chico, reaching Paradise CA by nightfall where most of the town was destroyed. If you want to look at the terrain, see: https://goo.gl/maps/oX2ZmL77AYA2 Heading north-east from Pulga is a fire break, and zoom in close enough you’ll see the power lines. Go a little farther north you’ll find the remnants of Mayaro, which in the late 1800’s was a famous resort town that is now just derelict ruins. Next to Mayaro is Camp Creek, and next to Camp Creek is a little hydro-electric generation facility where a large pipe runs down the mountain to a concrete block building containing turbines. That facility feeds into this power line. As you look at the map, understand that the terrain is extremely rugged and is very beautiful. Most of this is National Forest land, but the town of Pulga is not in the National Forest. FWIW, some friends of mine bought Pulga in 1994 (it’s possible to buy a whole town if it’s small enough), and I visited several times. It is saddening to realize that little town is now probably wiped off the map.
According to Wired, the Camp Fire started at 6:30 AM (about 15 minutes after PG&E reported the outage) and traveled 11 miles in 11 hours, which is a tremendous speed for a wildfire. It burned 70,000 acres in 24 hours and at the time Wired wrote that report it had spread to 100,000 acres. The smoke from the fire is creating unhealthy conditions as far away as San Jose (where I live), where the air quality index has been in the unhealthy range for the last two days. What fueled this fire? On the one hand it’s the dry vegetation, and on the other it’s a strong wind from the East flowing down the mountains. That wind not only propelled the fire, it also dried the vegetation even further.
This Facebook posting from the National Weather Service office in Sacramento clearly shows the effect of the wind coming from the east. The picture comes from the afternoon of November 8, the day the fire began.
The Wired article gets us to the other point. The backdrop behind this story is climate change and the warming climate. The weather is already a few degrees warmer than it should be this time of year, and California has famously had several years of extreme low rainfall and a hotter-than-normal climate. Several dry years left dry vegetation across the state, and immediate conditions (the strong wind from the east) made it even dryer. Adding an unfortunate power line issue made for a kind of perfect storm.
If Northern California had received anywhere near the typical amount of autumn precipitation this year (around 4-5 in. of rain near #CampFire point of origin), explosive fire behavior & stunning tragedy in #Paradise would almost certainly not have occurred. (1/n) #CAfire #CAwx pic.twitter.com/2LBKjSVBMF
— Daniel Swain (@Weather_West) November 10, 2018
Yeah, what he said. Rainfall has been abnormally low, and the vegetation is dry.
Critical fire weather conditions expected tomorrow across much of northern CA and a large part of coastal southern CA. Extremely critical conditions expected in much of coastal southern CA. These conditions will affect the #CampFire and the #WoolseyFire #CAwx pic.twitter.com/8YxH90wnTM
— NWS SPC (@NWSSPC) November 10, 2018
The National Weather Service is warning that current weather conditions mean fire risk remains high.
Look again at the NWS Sacramento picture and think about all the terrain which is NOT burning in this picture. This one fire is causing major havoc, it destroyed a whole city and is threatening another, the smoke plume is creating unhealthy air conditions in the SF Bay Area 150 miles away, all that from one fire. If climate change predictions are correct this specific terrain will get dryer and dryer, and there will be a time when it’s not just one fire of this magnitude but two or three. How will California’s fire fighters be able to respond to that many fires? How unhealthy will our air be? What is the climate change impact of releasing the carbon stored in those forests?
The cause of this fire is not forestry management practices, but the warming climate and dry local conditions. And probably lax maintenance on PG&E’s part — because this is not the first massive fire started because of PG&E power lines. According to the NY Times PG&E’s liability for the Tubbs Fire. that destroyed part of Santa Rosa last year, is over $17 billion. That fire, too, was sparked by downed PG&E power lines. Maddeningly, the California Legislature has passed legislation allowing PG&E and other utilities to pass along such costs to their customers rather than having the costs be carried by the utility companies.
When President Trump blames California’s forestry management practices, as he has done several times this year, he is lying, as he does continuously.
The LA Times made it even clearer just how many ways President Trump is incorrectly blaming forestry management.
- The fires in southern California are “urban interface fires” meaning they’re occurring in places adjoining urban areas, and are not under forestry management.
- Forestry management is not a factor in the Camp Fire described above, nor with the Tubbs Fire that destroyed part of Santa Rosa last year.
- With the Camp Fire you have dry grass and other dry vegetation among scattered pine and oak trees.
- With the Tubbs Fire, the terrain is covered by grassland with the occasional oak tree, and is also not under forestry management. Instead there are a ton of vineyards – it being Napa County and Sonoma County.
Another NY Times article notes that:
Nearly 60 percent of California’s 33 million acres of forestland are owned by the federal government, according to a 2018 report by the California Legislative Analyst’s Office. An additional 25 percent of the state’s forests are privately owned, and about 14 percent are owned by industrial owners like timber companies. State and local governments own just 3 percent of the state’s forests.
As is par for the course with President Trump, he is flatly wrong. Further he is wasting all our time by forcing us to evaluate and rebut his lies.
Governor-Elect Gavin Newsom responded:
Lives have been lost. Entire towns have been burned to the ground. Cars abandoned on the side of the road. People are being forced to flee their homes. This is not a time for partisanship. This is a time for coordinating relief and response and lifting those in need up. https://t.co/sAZ3QULV8G
— Gavin Newsom (@GavinNewsom) November 10, 2018
“At this moment, thousands of our brother and sister firefighters are putting their lives on the line to protect the lives and property of thousands,” said Brian Rice, the president of the California Professional Firefighters, which represents more than 30,000 firefighters and paramedics. “Some of them are doing so even as their own homes lay in ruins.”
— Michelle Jordan (@mjjordan2001) November 10, 2018
Increased frequency of forest fires is one of the predicted consequences of global warming. Scientists have been warning of this and other problems, like increased wars, conflicts over resources, resource shortages, and more, for years.Electric-Safety-Incident-Reported-Pacific-Gas-Electric-Incident-No-181108-9002
- We must pressure Biden over climate despite choosing Kerry as climate representative - November 25, 2020
- Tesla Autopilot danger from “passive vigilance” effect - October 24, 2020
- CALFire seizes PG&E equipment investigating cause of Zogg Fire in 2020 wildfire season - October 10, 2020
- Protect yourself from unhealthy air in wildfire zones - September 12, 2020
- 5+ million acres burned, choking smoke, Climate Change accelerated - September 12, 2020
- La Nina develops, promising longer 2020 fire and hurricane season - September 10, 2020
- California wildfires 2020, over 2 million acres burned - September 9, 2020
- Disease risk higher in highly polluted areas – COVID-19 risk greater? - April 1, 2020
- Conservative values failing USA as EPA guts fuel efficiency standards, fails with COVID-19 response - April 1, 2020
- SunSpec aims to help Veterans transition to clean energy jobs - March 31, 2020